Select Page

Top 10 Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets

If you are in the mood for a fresh-out-of-the-oven batch of cookies, one of our top 10 stainless steel cookie sheets might help you accomplish that goal. Stainless steel baking sheets are becoming more popular due to their durability and lack of coatings or toxins that can leach into your food. Easy to clean and built to last, stainless steel pains rival aluminum in that they won’t alter the taste of your recipes or cause discoloration. While some chefs worry that they will stick, just a light spray of non-stick coating will help your baked goods slide easily off the pan. Curious about our top picks? Read on.

1. Norpro 12 Inch x16 Inch Stainless Steel Cookie Sheet

Norpro’s stainless steel cookie sheets have a shallow rim on three sides and one open side so you can slide your baked goods easily off the surface. Available in two sizes; 12×16 and 12×15, these baking sheets have been a favorite in home kitchens for decades. Constructed of heavy-gauge, 18/0 stainless steel, they lay completely flat for evenly baked cookies, biscuits, and other delectables. Norpro recommends hand washing.

Norpro Top Ten Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets

2. Fox Run 44927 14 Inch x 17 Inch Stainless Steel Cookie Sheet

This 14X17 18/0 grade stainless steel cookie sheet by Fox Run resists warping and is perfect for everyday use. If you bake a lot of cookies, this is one of the best cookie sheets for the money. Rimmed on three sides for easy gripping and flat on one edge, it’s easy to slide baked goods off the pan and onto a cooling rack with little fuss.

Fox Run Top Ten Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets

3. Focus Foodservice Commercial Bakeware Stainless Steel-Sheet Pan

This commercial-grade sheet pan this sturdy 20-gauge stainless steel sheet pan by Focus Foodservice is bound to become your new favorite bakeware piece. Measuring 13 by 18 by 1-inch, it is NSF approved and resists pitting and corrosion. It features open bead edges and can be cleaned easily with a soft dry cloth. Perfect for making sheet cakes, jelly rolls, cookies, roasted vegetables, and more, this versatile and inexpensive cookie sheet is built to last.

Focus Foodservice Top Ten Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets

4. TeamFar Baking Sheet Set of 2 Stainless Steel Baking Pans

TeamFar makes some of the best cookie sheets on our list, and in this case, you get twice the value. This set of two is constructed of pure 430 18/0 stainless steel with smooth rolled edges and a mirror finish. Measuring 16 x 12 x 1 inch each, these pans are versatile enough to bake, roast, and even use as serving trays. Dishwasher safe, they can also be cleaned by using a soft dry cloth or warm soapy water. For evenly cooked baked goods and no warping, staining, or sticking, these pans are ideal.

TeamFar Top Ten Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets

5. Lindy’s Stainless-Steel Heavy Baking Sheet

Whether you are in the mood for fish sticks, fries, cookies, or biscuits, this gorgeous pan from Lindy’s has you covered. Measuring 17 x 12 x 1-Inches, The smooth dent, and scratch-resistant surface makes it simple to clean with a clean dry cloth or hot soapy water.  Constructed of heavy-duty 18/8 stainless steel and designed by the Amish, this baking sheet will last for years to come.

Lindy Top Ten Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets

6.All-Clad 9003TS 18/10 Stainless Steel Baking Sheet

This versatile and heavy-duty stainless-steel baking sheet by All-Clad is one of the top baking sheets on the market. It can withstand high temperatures (up to 600 degrees), so you can roast, broil, bake, or braise without worrying about warping. The flat surface and slightly raised rim keep juices and fats from running over, while one raised side allows you to get a good grip on the pan. This pan is built for longevity and is induction and dishwasher safe. It measures 14×17 inches, is made in the USA and comes with a limited lifetime warranty.

All-Clad Top Ten Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets

7. Aspire 304 Stainless Steel Tray Cookie Sheet Baking Pan

The 16-inch x 12 inch aspire is one of the cheapest cookie sheets on our list but is rugged enough to serve as an everyday staple in the home kitchen. Made of high quality pure 304 stainless steel, it features rolled edges and a mirror finish. High, one-inch sides prevent liquids from spilling over, making it ideal for cooking ribs, chicken wings, bacon, and more.

Aspire Top Ten Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets

8. P&P CHEF Stainless Steel Cookie Sheet Baking Pan Tray

P&P Chef is another inexpensive brand that is well-reviewed and perfect for the home kitchen. This 16x12x1 inch cookie sheet features a mirrored finish and is dishwasher safe for easy cleanup. A light spritz of non-stick cooking spray is all this pan needs to help your baked goods slide right off. Smooth, rolled edges and a deep rim keeps juices in the pan and off the bottom of the oven.

P&P CHEF Top Ten Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets

9. Boxiki Kitchen Stainless Steel Baking Sheet Pan

This heavy gauge brushed stainless steel cookie sheet by Boxiki measures 14×11 inches, and features silicone grip handles for ease of use. Warp, Rust, and dent resistance, this inexpensive baking tray can withstand temperatures up to 445 degrees and is freezer and dishwasher safe. Ideal for cookies and baked goods, your order comes with an eBook titled “Top 72 Delightful Sheet Pan Recipes” to get you started. This is the perfect gift for first-time bakers as well as those looking to replace their old baking sheets.

Boxiki Kitchen Top Ten Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets

10. Yododo Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets with Cooling Racks (set of 2)

This economical cookie sheet set from Yododo will have you baking cookies by the dozen in no time at all. Each of the 18/0-gauge stainless steel baking sheets also comes with a cooling rack. Featuring solid construction, rolled sides, and a mirrored polish, the pans are dishwasher safe and easy to clean. A spritz of non-stick cooking spray will make these pans completely non-stick without any toxic chemicals. The sheets measure 16 x 12 x 1 inches and are ideal for pizza, baked goods, fries, and more.

Yododo Top Ten Best Stainless Steel Cookie Sheets



By BCR Writing Staff

August 2019